What is the “Does it Make Sense?” Reading Prompt?

So, your child is reading along and comes to a word she doesn’t know. What do you do?  

Do you tell her to sound it out? Say the sounds?  No. You ask her what word would make sense here.
Children use basically three reading strategies when learning to read:
Does it make sense?
Does is sound right?
Does it look right?
The most POWERFUL  of these is the first one – Does it make sense?  Reading for meaning.

Mother and Daughter Reading Together --- Image by © Royalty-Free/Corbis

You’ll need to know about each of these reading strategies as you begin teaching your child. It’s quite simple. But, for this post, I’ll demonstrate the first one:

red-riding-hood

Does it make sense?

Complete these sentences:
Little Red Riding ____________ was such a nice, little girl.
“I’m going to ___________ you”, said the Wolf.
“Go straight to Granny’s ___________ and don’t stop to talk to any ____________.”
How did you know what the words were?  I didn’t see you using phonics! No letters, no phonics.  Aha! I knew it! You used the context or meaning of the story.  The word that you chose made sense.
This meaning strategy is the most powerful.  It drives reading. I can’t stress this enough.
The meaning of the story in your child’s head is like a scaffolding.  As your child reads along and stops when she comes to a word she doesn’t know, her brain is working hard to make meaning, to make sense. What could this word be? What word would make sense here? Each word choice your child makes has to fit. It has to make sense given what the story is about.

child wondering

This is precisely the reason it’s okay to tell your child what the story is about briefly before he or she begins to read it.  You are providing that much-needed scaffolding. You do this when you’re teaching how to read. On the other hand, when you’re reading a story to your child for pleasure, you don’t have to tell them what the story is about. Surprises are fun!


So, what about phonics? What about telling your child to just “sound it out”?   

Phonics alone does not work.  Blasphemy, you say?
Okay, Smartypants, sound out this word by sounding out each letter:  the
Did it work?  No?  Hmmm.
How about this word?   saw
Did it work?  No.
What about this word?  rough
Not having much luck, are you?  Do you think it might be a tad frustrating for your child if you tell him or her to just “sound it out”?

Asian Girl

The process of learning to read is a magnificent accomplishment of the human brain. It’s easy and complex at the same time. Yes, phonics is important. It is important to know the letter names and their sounds, but that’s not all you need to know. It’s much more important to teach the reading strategies mentioned above.
As a teacher, I was fortunate to be trained in Reading Recovery. It is an early literacy intervention program invented by psychologist/educator, Marie Clay, from New Zealand. I worked with grade one students who were having the most difficulty learning to read. My job was to teach them these reading strategies because, for whatever reasons, they had not yet acquired them.  It was my greatest joy to see these little people become proficient readers over a few short months once they got the hang of things.  I taught them much more than the letter names and sounds.
 For tips on teaching letter names and sounds, please see my previous blogs – How to Teach Your Child the Alphabet  and More Ways to Teach Your Child the Alphabet.
In the next post, I’ll show you how to teach the “Does it Make Sense?” reading strategy to your child.

cartoon_reading

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s